Stay up to date
Get the latest news, resources, and guides on email and lifecycle marketing—straight to your inbox.
Picture this!
It’s 8 AM, and you’re sipping your first coffee of the day while scrolling through your inbox.
The number catches your eye – 50 unread emails. You sigh, knowing most will be destined for the trash without so much as a click.
But wait…
There it is. That one email you actually look forward to seeing. It’s not just another newsletter – it’s more like a letter from a trusted friend or mentor.
Each week, it arrives packed with insights that genuinely help you grow your business. You find yourself savoring it, sometimes even saving it for when you can give it your full attention.
What makes this particular newsletter stand out in the sea of digital noise flooding your inbox? How does it cut through the clutter and become a must-read?
That’s exactly what I want to share with you today.
After years in the trenches of email marketing, I’ve come to fully understand the key ingredients that transforms a good newsletter into an unforgettable one. And trust me, it’s not about fancy designs or clever subject lines (though those don’t hurt).
It’s about something much more fundamental – and powerful.
Let’s dive in and explore these six key ingredients that make a newsletter truly stand out:
Remember when getting mail was exciting?
That’s the feeling we want to recreate with our newsletters.
Take Jake, for example. He runs a boutique coffee roastery. Instead of just listing his latest blends, Jake shares stories about his sourcing trips.
One of his emails painted a vivid picture of misty mountains, the earthy aroma of freshly picked beans, and the warm smiles of the farming families he works with.
He even included a recipe for a traditional coffee drink, straight from a local farmer’s kitchen.
His subscribers don’t just buy coffee; they feel like they’re part of Jake’s journey, one cup at a time.
This approach transforms Jake’s newsletter from a mere marketing tool into a storytelling medium that builds a genuine connection with his audience.
The truth is, your newsletter can’t be for everyone.
And that’s okay.
In fact, it’s better than okay – it’s essential for creating content that resonates deeply.
Think about your ideal reader.
What keeps them up at night? What are their dreams? What problem can you solve for them?
Once you nail this, your content practically writes itself.
I remember working with a fitness coach who was trying to appeal to everyone—from busy moms to hardcore bodybuilders.
Her newsletter was a mess of conflicting advice: one week about quick 5-minute workouts, the next about intense muscle-building routines.
We narrowed her focus to busy professionals looking to stay fit despite long work hours.
Suddenly, her content became laser-focused. She started sharing desk-friendly exercises, quick healthy lunch recipes, and stress-management techniques.
Her audience not only grew in numbers but in engagement. Comments like “It’s like you’re reading my mind!” became common, and her coaching program saw a 50% increase in sign-ups.
Imagine your favorite TV show airing randomly without any schedule.
Frustrating, right?
The same goes for newsletters.
Your readers should know exactly when to expect your email in their inbox.
I once worked with an insurance agent who was struggling with engagement. Their newsletter went out sporadically, whenever they had a product update or company news.
We switched to a consistent weekly schedule, releasing every Tuesday at 10 AM. Within three months, their open rates jumped by 35% and click-through rates doubled.
Why?
Because readers started looking forward to their Tuesday emails, often setting aside time specifically to read and engage with the content.
You don’t need a fancy design or complex content strategy to start.
Begin with a simple format and let it evolve based on your readers’ feedback.
One of my favorite success stories is a local bookstore owner in Nairobi. She started with a basic weekly email featuring one staff book recommendation.
Her first newsletter was nothing more than a book cover image, a short review, and a link to purchase. But it was consistent and genuine.
As she grew more comfortable, she added author interviews, reading challenges, and even a book club.
Now, her newsletter is the heart of a thriving community of book lovers.
In a world of polished corporate speak, authenticity stands out.
Share your failures along with your successes.
Be open about your learning process.
I once advised a young entrepreneur launching a meal-prep service, to share the story of a product launch that flopped.
His “Breakfast Bowl” line had been a disaster.
Alex was terrified to admit the failure publicly, but he took the plunge.
In his newsletter, he detailed what went wrong, what he learned, and how he was going to make it right. He even included a candid (and slightly humorous) photo of himself surrounded by the rejected breakfast bowls.
The result?
That email got more responses than any other he’d sent. People appreciated his honesty. Many shared their own business struggles. Some even offered suggestions for improving the product.
This transparency not only saved his reputation but strengthened his customer relationships.
The beauty of email marketing is that you get instant feedback. Use it!
Try A/B testing different subject lines, experiment with content formats, and always, always ask your readers what they want.
Take the case of a home decor brand I worked with. They noticed their click-through rates were declining. Instead of guessing, they asked their subscribers directly: “How can we make this newsletter more useful to you?”
The responses were illuminating. Readers wanted more practical tips, fewer product plugs.
So, we experimented. We created two versions of the next newsletter: one product-focused, one tip-focused.
The tip-focused version got 3x more clicks.
We didn’t stop there. We tested sending times, subject line styles (questions outperformed statements), and content length (shorter beat longer). Each test taught us something new about their audience.
Remember, your newsletter is a journey, not a destination. It’s about building relationships, one email at a time.
So start writing, keep improving, and watch as your newsletter becomes the one email your subscribers can’t wait to open.
I’d love to hear from you.
What newsletters do you love, and why?
What makes you open an email every single time it lands in your inbox? Share your thoughts and let’s learn from each other’s experiences!